Deseret News layoffs, revolution forges ahead

by Russ Hill on August 31, 2010

I used to ride the light rail train through the streets of downtown Salt Lake City to get from my office at KSL News to the Deseret News.

KSL has some of the nicest studios of any radio station in America. They’re huge. The newsroom is massive.

But, KSL had nothing on the expansive and luxurious conference rooms at the Deseret News. Those of us in the management of KSL were jealous every time we went to the Deseret News for our regular meetings.

Back then, we talked of ways to share our vast radio, TV, and print resources to own the news market throughout Utah. The meetings were friendly, but never productive. Radio people are used to wearing eight hats and acting with urgency but our peers – back then- were not.

Defense was the strategy of the day.  Protecting turf was much more important than preparing for the future.

I remember some in those meetings insisting that rushing something to the web instead of saving it for 10pm or Sunday morning was foolish – even destructive.  I quickly realized the limits of how much I could challenge their thinking.  After receiving a few phone calls I toned down my advocating for change.

And, then I left.

Those meetings in the conference rooms of the Deseret News weren’t unique.  The same scene has been, and is, playing out at legacy media companies across the world.

And yet, today’s announcement that the Deseret News laid off 43% of its newsroom staff brings me back to to those conversations years ago.  So much has changed since then. So much needed to change.

Forty-three percent is a staggering number. It’s a monster of a figure.

And, yet it comes just days after USA Today announced more than 130 layoffs.

Again, a huge number.

None of us enjoy watching someone lose their job. Especially in THIS economy.

And, yet, I wonder how many of my peers in the media truly understand how massive the revolution in our industry truly is. I’m convinced few get it.

My nine-year-old son came home from school with an assignment to write a newspaper article today. His mom tried to lobby him to get my help. Afterall, she said, “dad has written articles for newspapers before.” It’s true. In fact, a long piece I wrote after traveling to Indonesia to cover the tsunami appeared on the front page of the Deseret News.

The kitchen conversation made me wonder, “why are schools even bothering with newspaper article assignments anymore?” After all, how many children in the fourth grade will ever work for a newspaper.  My money is on very few, if any.

You can disagree. Many do. They fill the newsrooms and studios of radio, TV, newspapers, and magazines. They say they know the business is changing, but I worry most truly don’t get it.

A manager at a local Ford dealer was describing to me last week how the Internet is in the dashboard of the new 2011 Ford Explorer. The real estate where radios currently reside in cars is too valuable for companies like Google, Apple, Amazon, and others to not fight for it.

Don’t believe it?  How about this news article which says, “Technology and vehicles go hand in hand, but recently automotive manufacturers have been taking cues from Apple, Google and other digital trendsetters to make their machines more tech-friendly than ever.”

In fact, check out Ford’s website that raves about the USB ports and mobile Wi-Fi spot in the new vehicle.  Microsoft is Ford’s new dashboard partner.

Not Kenwood, RCA, or Pioneer.

When Wired is writing about new car consoles you know times are changing.

From Wired’s interview with the suits at Ford:  “While you’re driving to grandma’s house, your spouse can be finishing the holiday shopping and the kids can be chatting with friends and updating their Facebook profiles,” said Mark Fields, Ford president of the Americas. “And you’re not paying for yet another mobile subscription or piece of hardware because Ford will let you use technology you already have.”

Apple plans to announce their new AppleTV or iTV product Wednesday. Amazon is working on a streaming video provider.  Amazon.  TV.

The iPad delivers Time Magazine and the Wall Street Journal to my hands much faster and in a dramatically more user-friendly format.

And, yet so many in radio, TV, and print keep doing what they’ve been doing before. Some of the smart ones are incredibly active on Facebook and Twitter.  It’s a great start.  But, it’s just that: a start.

There will be more announcements in the months ahead like the one from the expansive newsroom of the Deseret News (a building that will be completely empty in 90 days).

Most of the managers at organizations who will make these announcements don’t even know they’re coming yet.  They’re too caught up in the present. And, their bosses deserve enormous blame for being blinded by today’s metrics which will be meaningless in a matter of months rather than years.

When was the last time radio, TV, or print staffers saw an email about page views, unique visitors, fans, followers, or downloads?  Instead, we continue to be consumed by ratings.  I understand it’s a matter of survival for many who work for antiquated bosses or companies.

So, what to do about all of this?

Embrace digital.

Those who spend great amounts of time building followers, creating new avenues of distributing their content, crossing over platform walls, learning how to do video, embracing a 24/7 consumption cycle, and finding ways to get their material on mobile devices will not only survive but will thrive in the years to come.

Now is the time for creativity.

Now is the time for working harder than before.

Now is the time for strategizing.

Now is the time for original ideas.

Now is the time for new metrics.

Now is the time for new leaders.

This media revolution has not yet destroyed all the duplication in TV, radio, and print. It will. Soon.

And, yet the future has never been brighter for the talented and hungry.

What an exciting and historic time.

Creation versus consumption

by Russ Hill on July 21, 2010

My summer of travel is mostly complete.  I will be blogging more regularly now that my schedule is returning to normal.

On my mind today is this idea of “creation versus consumption.”

I was talking to one of my former college roommates on the phone the other day.  It has been more than 10 years since we last spoke.  As we caught up he walked me through all the businesses he currently owns.  The list seemed to never end.  This long-time friend has done well for himself and frankly I wasn’t surprised at his level of success in various entrepreneurial ventures.

This former roommate seemed to never run out of energy when we were in college.  It’s obvious that he hasn’t changed.  The last few nights he and I have been exchanging some emails regarding a project we’re working on together.  I’ve been surprised at how quickly he gets things done.

That got me thinking.  This friend of mine has five children.  He’s more active than most in his community and religion.  He owns and operates more than half a dozen companies right now.

How does he get it all done?

The answer is his life is focused on creating, not consuming.

The most successful people I know are all alike in this area.  They are relentless in creating value all day.  Every day.  While most of the workforce simply puts in a certain numbers of hours every day at the job that provides them a paycheck, the very successful amongst us don’t concern themselves with hours but rather with creation.  Creation of things of value.

And, while most the workforce views their time away from the office as time to switch into a “consumption mode,” the very successful amongst us don’t flip that switch or change into that other mode.  They realize that when you are consuming you’re doing so at some level of expense to yourself.  When you are creating, you are increasing your wealth.

A good question to ask ourselves might be, how much time do I spend each day creating, and how much do I spend consuming?

Google’s Plan to Save News

May 21, 2010

The latest edition of Atlantic Monthly is a must read for anyone in the news business.  I know there are more articles each day about how to save the news business than any of us have time to read.  But, this one is worth your time to read and reread. Writer James Fallows is a [...]

Read the full article →

Embrace the criticism

May 18, 2010

I ate dinner with some peers at LuxBar in Chicago tonight (great steak by the way). Surrounding the table was a bunch of new media people.  We talking developers and the like.  All of these new media types work in traditional media.  And, the conversation turned to comments.  Those of you who work with big [...]

Read the full article →

Can’t afford research? No problem.

May 4, 2010

We’ve all heard it for years… the customer is the most important part of your business.  Most marketing books I’ve read over the years preach about how critical it is to listen to your customers.  You’ve got to be asking them about their experience with your products. I could not agree more on how important [...]

Read the full article →

Pandora Exposed: Behind the Scenes

April 28, 2010

If you haven’t seen this profile of Pandora on Nightline, you need to check it out. Learn how the killer music service works, their deal with Ford, their targeted advertising advantage, and how the iPhone changed everything.

Read the full article →

Radio’s Innovation Hurdle: Bonuses

April 27, 2010

Someone I interviewed for one of our top management positions at KTAR said something stunning to me. He works for one radio’s biggest companies in one of the country’s five largest media markets.  He is responsible for producing content that is expected to generate tens of millions of dollars in revenue. What was his bombshell? [...]

Read the full article →

Real health care reform

April 15, 2010

My brother was in Phoenix last weekend visiting us from his home in Texas. We got into a conversation about health care.  Sound familiar?  Who hasn’t been talking about health care with family, friends, or coworkers lately? So, my brother brings up that his doctor has recently dramatically changed his practice.  Maybe you’ve heard of [...]

Read the full article →

Expecting Greatness

April 13, 2010

I’m living in Interview World right now. I’ve spent countless hours interviewing for a Sports Program Director position, a News Director/Assistant Program Director position, and now a Talk Show Host position. The interview process involves hours and hours of time on the phone with candidates across the country and meeting after meeting of people we’re [...]

Read the full article →

Showing our sense of humor

April 2, 2010

April 1st used to mean nothing to me.  But, after I joined the team at KTAR that changed. Long ago the station started a tradition of pulling a prank on its listeners on April Fools Day.  It went away during KTAR’s stormy period.  And, two years ago, we brought the tradition back. Each year I [...]

Read the full article →